Status: Dubious product
This seems like it should be a joke, but I don't think it is. Reference Audio Mods is selling
wooden knobs for Silver Rock stereo equipment (to replace the standard metal knobs). They claim these knobs will greatly improve sound quality:
The point here is the micro vibrations created by the volume pots and knobs find their way into the delicate signal path and cause degradation (Bad vibrations equal bad sound). With the signature knobs micro vibrations from the C37 concept of wood, bronze and the lacquer itself compensate for the volume pots and provide (Good Vibrations) our ear/brain combination like to hear... way better sound!!
And they're asking $485.00! I refuse to believe that wooden knobs would make any difference in the sound quality of stereo equipment.
Related Posts:
Nov 08, 2005:
Altmann Tube-O-Lator Lacquer
Comments
It would qualify for the $1,000,000 prize, if it produced a detectable difference in a double blind test, but the manufacturers are too busy to apply.
That depends. Do the wooden knobs go to eleven?
Look at
http://www.audio-consulting.ch/sr_pot.htm
and
http://www.audio-consulting.ch/C37_wooden_knobs.htm
So while I reserve judgement till a later date, I will say it's not as ridiculous as it might seem at first glance.
Also, the only people the have the type of equipment these knobs are made for would not be an audio "newb" so they should have a fairly good idea of what they are getting into.
Also, no one is suggesting that replacing your old Sony stereo's knobs with custom wood ones will make any difference....this seems to be a specialized application directed at true audiophiles.
The link posted by Cranky Media Guy in the Tube-O-Lator Lacquer comments (http://www.ilikejam.dsl.pipex.com/audiophile.htm for the lazy,) has them listed as frauds, though obviously that doesn't mean much, what with it being the web. Still, logically, what are they going to do? Vibrate less? Not distort the sound waves that happen to pass through the knob quite as much as a metal knob would? I certainly wouldn't have pegged them as making the sound "much more open and free flowing with a nice improvement in resolution".
I don't claim to have particular knowledge on the subject, however, there doesn't seem like there would be enough of an audible difference to justify paying upwards of $900 for these (2 knobs. $7100 if you include the box), if one at all.
"Also, the only people the have the type of equipment these knobs are made for would not be an audio "newb" so they should have a fairly good idea of what they are getting into."
Chuck, you seem to be operating on the assumption that people who have the disposable income to buy very high-end stuff automatically know what they're buying. I wouldn't say that that is necessarily correct. I think there are a LOT of products on the market which have bells and whistles to justify a high price but don't actually work any better than their cheaper counterparts. For salient examples, check out Sharper Image or Hammacher-Schlemmer.
The main reason I assumed this product was not targeted at newbs with money is that most newbs with money simply go to a high end electronics store and purchase whatever is the latest and greatest. They do not, I repeat, do not build their own freaking stereo systems although they might hire someone to build it.
Bottom line, if you don't know, then you really shouldn't pass judgement. I found this site that seems pretty informative but haven't had the chance to look into it too much yet.
http://www.audioholics.com/techtips/audioprinciples/index.php
what all these audiophile gimmicks fail to remember, is they're using the same source material.. either vinyl, or cd (!)
were wooden knobs, and other gimmicks used in the recording studio?
garbage in, garbage out.
Frankly, the high end audio market is about at reliable as any other pseudoscience.
Professional audio devices not only have good quality pots (smooth electrical resistance graph, no particles (= the static when turning a volume knob)) but their other parts are also of high quality (resistors, filters on seperate boards, ...) All of these will create some static while some filter it out.
So any static still present, from a potentiometer, is so small that even if a wooden knob would work, the change would still be beneath the audio resolution of any recording device or speaker (and thus inaudible).
Sometimes the truth is so obvious to the casual observer that you don't really need to be in the "know." However, if you feel so strongly about it, I'll give some of my friends in the music production business a call today and ask them what they think about this product.
Passable point perhaps. Anyway I do know and my judgement is that this is a nonsense.
There you go, just saved you $500 or so. No need to thank me sir, it's my job. 😊
Peter, I am perfectly happy with my low end set up and was not contemplating wooden knobs for it but all the same, it is very kind of you to look out for us simple folk 😊
Supposing that using wooden knobs on a high-end stereo outfit really does somehow make the sound better, why couldn't I whittle my own from a piece of scrap lumber at a total cost of ... nothing?
The audiophile market is similar to the wine connoisseur market in that it includes a percentage of pretentious dingbats who exercise little or no judgement or critical thinking when introduced to gadgets like gold-plated speaker wire, fancy-shmancy power leads, wine magnets, etc.
A lot of high end audio gear these days doesn't use potentiometers. The knobs are connected to little optical encoders that send digital pulses to the logic to increase or decrease gain in a circuit. Changing the knob will have no more effect on the detectable sound than changing your shorts.
The real giveaway is that none of these people (or the twits who endorse their products) are willing to subject their products to a real double blind test. There are forums full of their nonsensical arguments about why double blind tests wouldn't prove anything or "aren't fair". If there actually were any real, objective tests to quote from they would let you know loud and clear. Instead all you ever see is testimonials from satisfied suckers, sorry... I mean customers, and condescending "experts".
The bottom line is: if you can't tell the difference why waste your money?
OK, here's a question for you audio-knowledgeable types:
Supposing that using wooden knobs on a high-end stereo outfit really does somehow make the sound better, why couldn't I whittle my own from a piece of scrap lumber at a total cost of ... nothing?
_____________________________________
Gary, I have already admitted my lack of knowledge so I don't really qualify as an "audio knowledgeable type" but I can refer you to a page I linked to previously.
http://www.audio-consulting.ch/C37_wooden_knobs.htm
Scroll to the bottom and you will see some unfinished knobs. I don't see any reason a halfway decent carpenter couldn't make them. The onlt specs seem to be the type of wood (solid beech in this case) as well as a bronze core which they claim achieves much better sound than any other metal or plastic.
"The music doesn't become sound until it reaches the speakers, folks. Until it is converted into sound in the speakers, it is nothing but a stream of signal being passed down the wires, or nowadays, thru a wireless transmission, sometimes."
Exactly correct, Mr. Stork. This whole "wooden knob" thing is a big joke on people who think that the most expensive thing must automatically be the BEST thing. Like another poster said, these would have about as much impact on the sound coming out of your speakers as changing your shorts would.
Although Barnum never said, "There's a sucker born every minute," the guy who DID was about 30 seconds off. Or as Frank Zappa said, hydrogen isn't the most common element in the Universe, stupidity is.
"One of them has been an 'expert' for probably 20 years now, and he once spent $10,000 on gold-plated speaker cable that sounds exactly like the cable that came with the system. He refused to allow us to perform a blind test of his ability to distinguish between the two."
Isn't that interesting? Why, it's almost as if, on some level, he KNEW that his ridiculously expensive cable didn't do squat to the audio. I mean, if they were worth $20k, why wouldn't he want to PROVE to you that he knew what he was talking about? The ability of the human mind to bullshit itself is amazing, isn't it?
I might start producing high-end audiophile equipment made out of lovely polished wooden boxes (just like the old days). Wow, what could I charge for a wooden amp?
"People are like this, always. They are narrow-minded like the topicstarter and most of the crowd who replied, too stupid to figure out how it is possible, and too protective for their tiny, narrow-minded world by refusing to even think."
Well, why don't you explain to us fools how exactly wooden knobs can demonstrably improve the sound of an otherwise unaltered stereo system...you know, since you're so much smarter and open-minded than the rest of us. It's OK to use small words so that we simpletons can follow what you say, by the way.
What creates better sound is the source (cassette vs. CD), the type of wood the speakers are made out of, the speakers themselves (2-way vs 3-way, woofer size, all components working?), speaker cable vs. wire used (cable sounds better), having the proper ohms and voltage, how EQ and loudness are used, etc.
As others have said, this is a cash grab, will likely make a plastic stereo look like shit and would never pass a double blind test.