Status: Real
I've received quite a few emails about the following story, presumably because it seems like something lifted from Monty Python's Ministry of Silly Walks. A family in Turkey contains five siblings who have apparently never learned how to walk on their feet. They still walk on all fours, with the weight of their upper bodies supported by their wrists (wrist walking, as opposed to knuckle walking, which is what apes do). You can check out
a video of one of these wrist walkers on the website of Turkish researcher Uner Tan.
The case of these wrist walkers is far too widely reported to be a hoax. Apparently there's even a BBC documentary about them in the works. Scientific interest in them stems from the light they might shed on a long-standing debate about how humans evolved the ability to walk upright. Were humans knuckle walkers (like other primates) or wrist walkers before they started walking on two feet?
There's also debate about whether these Turkish siblings are merely suffering from a form of brain damage and never learned how to walk upright (this theory is argued by
a team of British researchers... their paper is at the top of the list of articles), or are the siblings a case of reverse evolution (the Turkish researcher Uner Tan is arguing this). Whatever the case may be, none of it seems to be a hoax.
World Science has a couple of informative articles about the controversy (
article 1,
article 2).
Comments
Reverse evolution? Ha!
A hoax by 5 kids who crave attention? Ding! Ding! Ding!
Three possible explanations:
1. Lazy parents.
2. Family of alcoholics.
3. Gastro-intestinal problems.
Didn't the British team attribute their gait to a form of ataxia?
"All five of the quadruped siblings
Not to mention, a child with spina bifida (that survives infancy) may have problems walking upright, and I have seen SB kidss bent over at the waist walking similarly to the above people.
Since I'm not a doctor, I can't really think of any other diseases that can cause this...but as mentioned above - there most deffinately are.
I certain arab countries people will do anything to earn a couple of quid.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=379134&in_page_id=1770
From the last paragraph:
The documentary, to be shown on BBC2 on Friday, March 17, is called The Family That Walks On All Fours.
Amazing what happens when genes get mixed up.
Believe it of not, it is actually possible for evolution to 'slip up' sometimes.
That said, I can see why some would have a problem believing the story but we do all learn from what we hear and see. It's also possible that one of the siblings that has this throwback and because the other 4 siblings saw this they decided to copy.
I'm not sure what I think about interbreeding as I do wonder if the warnings of disabilities and deformed foetuses is scaremongering to put those that have thought about it off the idea as it is socially unacceptable. I'm guessing the parents of this brood are brother and sister as they are 'very closely related'(ewww).
Maybe if they both had a recessive backward evolution gene the fact they are related would make the odds of this gene appearing in their children much higher.
Anyway, I'm just speculating and it'll be interesting to see the documentry to see if it is convincing.
I can be convinced one way or the other and just get annoyed when people dismiss the idea of something new (or old) as out of the question for no real reason. If these people wanted to make a 'quick buck' would they not have done that 25 yrs ago so they could then revert back to walking on just 2 limbs. 30 something years isn't my idea of a quick buck!
There were many strange deformed children born out of this. Babies that only had a mouth and indents were the eyes and nose should be. They had one child that lived to be about 8. He was born with teeth and small bumps rather than ears. To look at him that's all you would see, but at the age of 1 or 2 they had to keep him penned up because he would bite chunks out of the other children.
I remember my grandmother visiting them and they would poke food through the cage at him. There were others that you never saw but just heard growling like animals in a back room somewhere. They too were isolated in the back woods - they owned 60 acres with no one around for miles. I can only remember 2 or 3 being somewhat functional. This was back in 1940's early 50's and something I will never forget.