Status: Almost definitely an urban legend
The
Leicester Mercury has printed
a spooky story that sounds very much like an urban legend. (Though I know some people say that true urban legends don't involve the supernatural, so I guess it would be a ghost legend.) Since I don't believe in ghosts, I'm assuming that the story is mostly b.s. But I'm curious if any parts of it are true.
The story goes like this: In 1950 Dr Guiseppi Stoppolino of Camerino University was testing an Italian clairvoyant named Mario Bocca to see if his powers were real. During the test Bocca picked up a message from a dead woman calling herself Rosa Spadoni, who claimed that she had been buried alive back in 1939. Stoppolino and Bocca searched for the grave of Rosa Spadoni, but couldn't find it until they realized that her tombstone bore her married name, Menichelli. They convinced a court to exhume Rosa Menichelli's coffin, and, sure enough, discovered evidence that she had been buried alive. As the
Leicester Mercury tells it, "There was little more than a skeleton left in the coffin, but the spine was arched in an attempt to lift the lid, and the fingers still clawed at the woodwork."
A version of the story can also be found on the
World of the Strange website, where they add this ending:
"The outraged public reaction that followed rocked Italy and even threatened to bring down the government. Within months, Dr. Stoppolini succeeded in his crusade for mandatory embalming of the dead. As the story spread to other European countries, burial practices were also hastily changed."
You would think that an event like this that supposedly changed burial practices in Europe would be easy to confirm, but a google search brings up almost nothing. Just about the only part of the story I can confirm is that there really is a Camerino University in Italy. I can't confirm the existence of Dr. Guiseppi Stoppolino, Mario Bocca, or Rosa Spadoni. However, a post (in Italian) on
Google Groups revealed that the Spadoni story was told in
The World's Greatest Ghosts, which came out in 1984, written by Nigel Blundell and Roger Boar. I'm wondering if Blundell and Boar's account is the first published account of the story. And, if so, did they simply make it up?
Comments
That alone would make me question this story.
Until somebody can document some of the above, I'm going to assume the whole story is bogus.
By the way, I would say that "The outraged public reaction that followed rocked Italy and even threatened to bring down the government" must be a wild exaggeration, except that bringing down the Italian government isn't as big a deal as you might think. Italy has had somewhere around 100 different governments (in the sense of different parties or coalitions being in control) since World War II, from which we can conclude that it doesn't take a whole lot to topple an Italian adinistration, nor do these changes of government seem to be too traumatic to the Italian people.
Hmm, I'd say these are too radically different things. I'm not scared of cemeteries, but please don't bury me alive.
It's sort of like coining a single word-- Tigracurdaphobia, let's say, that means "fear of tigers, or of lemon custard."
Er, I mean, "an Italian administration."
Anyway I actually have that book, and that's where I heard the story. It's basically the same as what's up there except apparently the person they were testing was actually in a classroom, and the Dr was offering classes on paranormal stuff or something. They got her in there, she apparently gave personal messages to the students posing as their dead relatives, and then went on about being burried alive before collapsing.
Rest of it is more or less the same.
Nah, really?
Posted by Christopher in Joplin, Missouri on Tue Feb 14, 2006 at 07:30 AM
The way you describe it, it sounds like they tested it for a person who was merely keeping still. In order for a person to be thought dead and then buried, their breathing and circulation would have to be drastically slowed down. This would lessen the amount of oxygen needed by the body. Plus, some people get buried in larger coffins than others, and if you have a small person buried in a largish coffin, that would leave even more airspace. Did Mythbusters take all that into consideration?
In my opinion, it is possible to have had people buried alive. But to go so far as to say they survived for any length of time (beyond a few hours at best) is drastically stretching the truth.
Think about it. The person is assumed dead. Even if it is an open casket funeral at graveside, the person is still at one point, sealed into the coffin when the lid is closed, at which point his oxygen supply is being consumed while he is dead. The person is usually lowered into the ground, and a family member throws the first shovel of dirt into the grave. The coffin usually is not covered completely until after every attendee has left, and then not right away. At best, maybe an hour after the last person left. If the dead person was going to come back to life, now is the best time for him to do so, as he's been sealed in that box for at least two hours, and his oxygen supply is running real low...
For somebody to have been in the condition to have been taken for dead in the first place, probably would never be able to regain the strength enough to leave claw marks in the top of the coffin in the first place, much less to have the oxygen supply left over in a flat-top wood coffin (as was the style of most coffins in the era of the myths), AFTER exhausting the energy required to leave claw marks in the coffin lid in the first place!!!
My opinion: nothing but ghost stories, better left for the camp fire...
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, there were numerous inventions patented to prevent or remedy the supposed problem of people being (accidentally) buried alive, including emergency air supplies, alarm systems, and so on. Some of these must have actually been used for at least a few burials, but I'm not aware of any recorded case of someone having been rescued after being buried alive.
On the other hand, there are many reports of people being discovered to be still alive during preparation for burial or while awaiting burial, but that's a different question, isn't it?
The most credible stories of people regaining consciousness and being rescued after premature disposal, in my opinion, are those where the unfortunate person was placed in an above-ground tomb or crypt, not buried underground. That allows a possibility that fresh air could be seeping in somewhere.
Anywho, I don't think this really happened.
some of you say its not possible to be buried alive :\
but [and this is true] i know this is true, because my sister learnt it in year 11 i think, or year 12, in one of her health classes i think, that this guy actually learnt to stop his heart for like im not sure how long the time was, but a certain amount of time, and he told people not to bury him straight away if they thought he was dead, because he might not be...
and anyway, he "died", they buried him, and months later they dug up the coffin which had scratch marks on the inside of the lid...
:\
very scary...
i have no idea how you can learn to stop your heart, i didnt think it was possible!? :\ but i guess this dude did...god knows why he would want to do that...but yeah...
I've never understood people who say they want to be embalmed or cremated rather then buried in case they get buried alive. Tell me, how is getting embalmed alive or burned alive better?
today I read a book from 1988 written by Viktor Farkas."Unerklaerliche Phaenomene". He tells this story, too.
I
http://www.unicam.it/museomemoria/accademia/dromedario.htm
La Scienza e il Paranormale
Ci
http://michaelprescott.typepad.com/michael_prescotts_blog/2009/01/the-premature-burial.html
Best wishes,
Vitor