The Great Octopus Mystery
As a joke, a Peoria woman puts a baby octopus in her boyfriend's toilet. Her boyfriend gets home, finds an octopus in his toilet, and assumes it must have crawled there from out of the sewer. He calls the local paper and the city is soon caught up in the 'Great Octopus Mystery'
until the girlfriend calls up and sheepishly confesses.
Commenting is no longer available in this channel entry.