Is the “Hercules the World’s Biggest Dog” photo fake, as everyone has assumed?


This photo of "Hercules, the World's Biggest Dog" is one of the best known "hoax" viral images on the Web. It started circulating in early 2007, initially on its own, but soon the Internet had supplied an explanatory caption:
Hercules: The World's Biggest Dog Ever According to Guinness World Records
Hercules was recently awarded the honorable distinction of Worlds Biggest Dog by Guinness World Records. Hercules is an English Mastiff and has a 38 inch neck and weighs 282 pounds.
With "paws the size of softballs" (reports the Boston Herald), the three-year-old monster is far larger and heavier than his breed's standard 200lb. limit. Hercules owner Mr. Flynn says that Hercules weight is natural and not induced by a bizarre diet: "I fed him normal food and he just grew".... and grew. and grew.

The information in this caption is correct, but not when applied to the dog shown above. The text is actually taken from a description of an English mastiff named Hercules that was owned by power lifter John Flynn (shown below). So wrong dog!


But what are we to make of the top photo, the one of the giant dog being walked by the man and woman alongside the white horse? We know he's not Hercules, but who or what is he? Is he really that big?

The top debunking sites feel that the dog can't really be that large. For instance, David Emery calls the photo "an obvious hoax." Hoax-Slayer says, "It seems clear that the image has been cleverly manipulated, perhaps by replacing a picture of the man's horse with a disproportionally sized picture of a dog." TruthorFiction.com says, "the picture appears to be fabricated." Snopes alone is a little ambivalent. It says the photo appears to be "a digital manipulation," but it leaves open the possibility that the dog is a "freakishly large example of its breed."

The reason for the skepticism is that the dog appears to be a Neapolitan Mastiff (not an English Mastiff), and that breed is not known to get that big. Breeders say Neapolitan Mastiffs top out at 31 inches at the shoulder. But the dog in the photo seems to be around 36 inches at the shoulder, easily.

Also, just look at that beast. He's horse-sized! The photo has to be fake!

But it's worth noting here that the photo is actually one of a set of three photos of the dog, the couple, and the horse. Although the top photo is often detached from the set and circulates alone. Here are the other two photos:




The existence of three photos of the same dog gives me pause. Because it's easy to dismiss one image as a fake, but three photos is unusual, especially since the dog looks similarly massive in all three shots. Yes, all three photos could be fake. But then again, perhaps that dog really is freakishly big.

I'll say this: if the images are fakes, then they're good ones. Particularly the one of the couple sitting down with the dog. The shadows and the lighting look right. There are no obvious signs of manipulation — except for the bizarre size of the dog.

Often it's possible to debunk a fake image by finding the original, unaltered version of the photo. But other versions of these giant dog images have never surfaced. This suggests to me that if the images are fake, then the faker possesses the original copies of the images and has never made them public.

Nor have the man and women ever been identified, which is a shame because they could obviously shed light on what the deal is with the giant dog. Perhaps they have no desire to be Internet celebrities.

But wait! There could be a fourth image. While searching for pictures of Neapolitan Mastiffs, I came across this photo.


Perhaps I've been staring too long at my screen, but that looks to me like it could be the same dog and the same guy. Sure, the guy is a little older, wearing different clothes, has a goatee, and is squinting into the sun. But his features look the same. And the dog has a white patch on his chest like the dog in the "Hercules" photo, and he's wearing a studded collar (if you look closely you can see that the dog in the "Hercules" photo appears to be wearing a similar studded collar).

The dog in this fourth photo doesn't look quite as massive as the dog in the viral "World's Biggest Dog" photo. Nevertheless, it's a very big dog! Far bigger than most other Neapolitan Mastiffs.

Which suggests to me that there really is a giant Neapolitan Mastiff out there. Now perhaps his size was digitally exaggerated in the top photo that went viral. Or perhaps the angle of the shot exaggerated its size. Or perhaps the man and woman aren't that tall, which made the dog look larger than it really is relative to them.

I just don't know. But I don't think the "World's Biggest Dog" photo is the slam-dunk, has-to-be-photoshopped case that most other debunking sites have listed it as. I'd go with Snopes and leave open the possibility that the dog in the photo might actually be a "freakishly large example of its breed."

viral images Fake Photos of Very Large Animals

Posted on Tue Jan 21, 2014



More content from the Hoax Museum:

Comments

actually the dog is a Neapolitan mastiff,
Posted by marsha boyer  in  United States  on  Fri Jun 06, 2014  at  12:57 AM
hmmm
Posted by JERIC PANGANIBAN  in  DAVAO PHILIPPINES  on  Sun Jul 27, 2014  at  04:21 AM
I know the man who took these photos. That is his daughter and son in law's dog in England.
Posted by Matt Durham  in  st. louis, mo  on  Thu Feb 26, 2015  at  06:11 PM
The first photo is an obvious fake. The shadows don't match at all. Very long shadows made by the humans and a very short shadow that is too small, made by the dog. That makes me tend to believe the first 3 are fake (same subjects). In the last photo, a simple camera trick is used . The dog is much closer to the camera than the human and at an angle which subtley hides that fact.
Posted by Bill Morris  in  United States  on  Thu Apr 30, 2015  at  12:58 PM
Re Bill Morris comment, if you are referencing shadow size the Horse shadow is small also so that explanation is not evidence of photoshop. It seems most explanations of this image have been led by people's opinion that the image "can't be real" then they look for evidence to support their opinion rather than just looking for the truth. Bottom line who cares if the image is real, it's not impossible but so what! One way or another we'll never know unless the people in the image come forward with the dog and they obviously aren't interested in doing that. Good for them!
Posted by Paula Mc Bride  in  United Kingdom  on  Fri May 15, 2015  at  03:45 PM
Im sure many of you are like me and one of the first things you do in the moinrng is head here and check out the new post. Along with seeing the new posts, I'm also always checking out the blog roll rss feed and watching them grow, or shrink sometimes. In one of my past but all in all excellent site. Keep it up!
Posted by Muhamed  in  hMZccb0c  on  Tue Jun 30, 2015  at  04:12 AM
WHat???!!!... my family didn't bohetr to shared that earthquake to me.. maybe they just don't want me to worry about them there.. i could still remember how scary was it 2002 when it has that intensity... and to think that the wall of our neighbors collapsed because of it, and it was really scary like it was the end of the world. as we all woke up from a very deep sleep like the whole ground was rockin' cradling us to sleep....of what you did te lynn, that's really scary. as those two cabinets might be able to fall right to you.good thing nothing happens and no serious about what happened there...meri xmas...
Posted by Prajakta  in  3dyEMYQ2F  on  Wed Jul 01, 2015  at  12:20 PM
I'm imsrspeed you should think of something like that http://uedcbwte.com ypqvcnwyjae [link=http://gwepaegzmf.com]gwepaegzmf[/link]
Posted by Bertha  in  BnV9GNkm3  on  Wed Jul 01, 2015  at  06:19 PM
=NovaSdon't worry, sis. no damages have been rtropeed naman. pero lakas talaga, as in!=Windmillwow! that's so sweet of you. thanks a lot for the nice words! i'm touched. you could be my superhero then. LOL.=Mariayes sis. we're okay. maayo na lang kay dali ra nahuman kung nidugay pa to, unsaon na lang. haaay, kahadlok!=prettymomthanks sis. will grab the award soon ha. ingatz!
Posted by Victoria  in  c4aiO6awoFT  on  Fri Jul 03, 2015  at  04:42 PM
Ah, the thgins we carry on our backs I'm with you in that I try to do so many thgins, to help so many friends, to solve so many problems, to worry for everyone else, that sometimes I fear I might be crushed under the weight. Nice Post.From Diary of a Writer in Progress http://vsndaidpkr.com rllksvh [link=http://rnabrluvxe.com]rnabrluvxe[/link]
Posted by Saddam  in  EaOJJytsx7w  on  Sun Jul 05, 2015  at  12:51 PM
Incredible how possible can that be a dog like monster?
Posted by wester suah  in  monrovia,liberia  on  Tue Jul 07, 2015  at  04:08 AM