The Museum of Hoaxes
hoax archive hoax archive hoax archive hoax archive hoax archive
   
Hoaxes Throughout History
Middle AgesEarly Modern1700s1800-1840s1850-1890s
1900s1910s1920s1930s1940s1950s1960s1970s1980s1990s21st Century2014
Astrological Discrimination
Two days ago the Daily Mail published an article describing an unnamed "Salzburg insurance company" that seems to be practicing a form of astrological discrimination in its hiring. The company is said to have placed this ad in newspapers:

We are looking for people over 20 for part-time jobs in sales and management with the following star signs: Capricorn, Taurus, Aquarius, Aries and Leo.

When accused of discrimination, the company responded: "A statistical study indicated that almost all of our best employees across Austria have one of the five star signs." And a spokeswoman later followed up with this argument: "When an employer considers star signs and says: 'I want to only hire Pisces,' for an example, it must be assumed that within this group of people born under the sign of Pisces there are old and young people, women and women etc. It does appear like a certain limitation, but it is not discrimination."

The story has now begun to appear in other papers and websites, although the Daily Mail appears to be the sole original source. So is there any evidence the story is true? Not that I can find. My German-language skills aren't too good, but I can't find any sign of the story in papers such as the Salzburger Nachrichten.
JournalismPseudoscience
Posted by The Curator on Fri Feb 06, 2009


Old and young
women and women???
So men are never born
under pisces?
Posted by Sharruma  in  capable of finishing a coherent  on  Fri Feb 06, 2009  at  08:05 PM
I should add a [sic], because that wasn't a typo on my part.
Posted by The Curator  in  San Diego  on  Sat Feb 07, 2009  at  12:19 AM
It is discriminating... against intelligent, educated people.

Intelligent, education people would never apply for a job with a company that tried to enforce that kind of recruitment policy.

Typing while drunk, expect typos!
Posted by Richard@Home  in  Sheffield, Uk  on  Sat Feb 07, 2009  at  07:13 PM
Hi,

I know German and had a look. Apparently it looks like it was a job ad in the Salzburger Zeitung on february 1st. Several german sites also talk about it.

I could find it on the Salzburger site under the job ads:

http://www.salzburg.com/rubriken/php/pub_search_step2_job.php?ad=2e4$_mt6z4y-1e6-e8fj0fu

Fast translation of the text: We are looking for people for a side job in Sales/Management, preverably with following signs: they give six + a phone number.

But no company name and I did not get anywhere with googling the phonenumber.
Posted by Jo  in  The Netherlands  on  Sun Feb 08, 2009  at  03:50 AM
as far as i can tell, the phone number matches a:

EURO-FINANZ-SERVICE AG

Found on Austrian yellow pages:

http://www.herold.at/gelbe-seiten/salzburg/lw7ph/euro-finanz-service-ag-dipl-fw-walter-fletschberger/

prehaps a german speaker will have better luck finding more...
Posted by Jake  on  Sun Feb 08, 2009  at  07:21 PM
I wouldn't trust a story in the Daily Mail any more than you'd trust a story from the National Enquirer. It regularly prints urban legends, promotes flying saucers, ghosts, fake medicine, etc.
Posted by Croydon Bob  in  London, UK  on  Mon Feb 09, 2009  at  06:24 AM
OK - so one person says there was an an ad. I tried looking through the online paper and couldn't find it, but my German is very sketchy and the site acted very flaky when I connected to it.

But still - was there a STORY in the Salzburger Nachrichten, or any other German language media outlet??

The longer this drags on the more obvious it becomes that this is a prank either pulled on or by the Daily Mail.

Curt Steinmetz
Posted by Curt Steinmetz  in  rockville, md, usa  on  Wed Feb 11, 2009  at  12:28 PM
the story is (unfortunately) definitely true. I'll mail you all the relevant links (+ translation) shortly.
This caused quite an uproar then in Austria, so there also a few articles with this companies manager defending/justifying their way of recruiting.
Posted by Stiglitz E.  in  Reichenau  on  Sat Oct 20, 2012  at  08:59 PM
Commenting is no longer available in this channel entry.
All text Copyright © 2014 by Alex Boese, except where otherwise indicated. All rights reserved.