The Museum of Hoaxes
hoax archive hoax archive hoax archive hoax archive hoax archive
Hoaxes Throughout History
Middle AgesEarly Modern1700s1800-1840s1850-1890s
1900s1910s1920s1930s1940s1950s1960s1970s1980s1990s21st Century2014
The Lost Island of Hi-Brazil
In 1480 a fully-laden ship left the port of Bristol, England to sail west in search of the island of Hi-Brazil, which was believed to be somewhere off the coast of Ireland. It met with no success. Nor did the two ships which sailed the following year in search of the island fare any better. And the five ships captained by John Cabot which set sail in 1498 to search for Hi-Brazil came up equally empty-handed.

There was one very good reason why none of these ships could find Hi-Brazil: the island didn't exist, outside of legend.

Stories about the island had circulated around Europe for centuries, telling that it was the Promised Land of the Saints, an earthly paradise where fairies and magicians lived. But supposedly the island was surrounded by thick fog, hidden from the eyes of mortals.

Detail from the Catalan map of 1350 showing the location of Hi-Brazil.
(Image from Donald Johnson's Phantom Islands of the Atlantic)

Apparently quite a few people thought there might be something to these legends. Cartographers, in particular, were confident enough in the existence of the island to start putting it on maps in the mid 1300s. And its existence as a point on maps appears to have inspired all those ill-fated voyages during the late 1400s to find it.

Nisbet's Discovery of Hi-Brazil
We might forgive those European explorers who put their faith in a legend and went off searching for a phantom island. After all, often times there is some hidden truth behind legends. But we must raise a skeptical eyebrow when we encounter the tale of Captain John Nisbet, who set sail from France in September 1674 intending to return home to Ireland, but who claimed that enroute he accidentally found the fabled island of Hi-Brazil.

According to Nisbet's later description, his crew chanced upon the island after sailing through an especially thick cloud of fog. They disembarked on the island and discovered that it was inhabited by large black rabbits and a magician who lived alone in a castle. The magician informed them that the spell that had kept the island hidden from the eyes of mortals had been broken.

This was great news, and other people, upon hearing it, wasted no time in attempting to profit from it. In 1675 a man named Mathew Calhoon used Nisbet's account to file a request with King Charles I for a patent of ownership to the island of Hi-Brazil. It's not clear what the basis of his claim to the island was since, by his own admission, it was Nisbet who had found the island, not himself. Apparently he felt that the island should rightfully be his since he had read Nisbet's account. Unfortunately King Charles's reply to Calhoon is not recorded, but whether or not Calhoon ever received his patent is quite irrelevant, since the island was never found again. Evidently the spell had not been broken.

Links and References
  • Johnson, Donald S. (1994). Phantom Islands of the Atlantic: The Legends of Seven Lands That Never Were. Walker and Company, New York.
  • Adams, Percy G. (1962). Travelers and Travel Liars: 1660-1800. (Reprinted in 1980 by Dover Publications.)
Exploration and TravelGeographyFictitious PlacesHoaxes of the Middle Ages

That's why they called the country of Brasil, Brazil. Cartograohers thought that Hy-Braesal/Hi Brazil must be the South American east coast and was thefore the same place. It was also belevied that the Fountain of Youth was on Hy Brasel as well.

Posted by Paul Schmidt  in  New Zealand  on  Tue Jan 31, 2012  at  08:50 AM
Hy Brasil is not a hoax, but due to the rising sealevels it is now under the waters of the Atlantic Ocean
Posted by Rowie  in  Netherlands  on  Wed Sep 05, 2012  at  06:59 AM
A good example of sea level changes in this area of the world can be found in relation to the Isles of Scilly.

These islands were as recently as the roman period described as a single island and several sets of field walls have been discovered in the surronding shallows.;=&hnear=0x484008d08dabddfd:0x2057dab480b7fbe6,Isles+of+Scilly,+UK&gl=au&ei=EP6nUsCNBo3YoATKpIGICQ&sqi=2&ved=0CJYBELYD

Recent work with inhundating mapping points to the last great sea rise in world to have ocurred between 300 and 600 AD depending on local conditions. This then brings alive the prospect that some of these island myths might actually have a grain of truth in them remembered from the days of oral tradition.
Posted by Aaron  in  Australia  on  Wed Dec 11, 2013  at  12:12 AM
Submit a Comment

Note: Comments by non-members are all checked by a moderator before appearing on the site. This may take a while.

All text Copyright © 2014 by Alex Boese, except where otherwise indicated. All rights reserved.